Crazy St. Lucia’s

St. Lucia doesn’t take part of the most common rums bottled as single casks, but it’s not uninteresting however. I had the opportunity to taste this Cadenhead’s during a recent tasting night and it was truly surprising. I also heard good things from the Velier 2010 release so it’s time to explore more in depth the Saint Lucia island!

Velier St. Lucia 70th Anniversary 2010-2017 (58.6%, cask #734-0908 JD2, 267 bottles)

Colour: Gold.
Nose: The alcohol integration is nice but could have been slightly better. That’s a very expressive nose with a lot of solvents first. It has a typical St Lucia identity with leather, wood and herbal freshness. We have marzipan, almond liquor, honey, grains, mangoes, bananas, nutmeg, orange peels, roasted coconuts, white pepper and some acidity with unripe apples.
Mouth: Nice thick texture and that’s powerful in terms of aromas. Overripe papayas, brown sugar, brand new leather, peppermint, chilies, polished wood, blackcurrant, forest fruits, herbal notes, fuel and pine wood. That’s complex with a better alcohol integration than we had in the nose.
Finish: Long, warm and slightly drying. Forest fruits, vanilla, eucalyptus, burnt wood and honey.

It has the flame from a young rum, with the complexity than an older one. Good job Luca!

Score: 89

Cadenhead’s St. Lucia 1999-2008 (70.8%)

Colour: Gold.
Nose: The first nose is more austere than the Velier’s one, it’s also more structured. In a blind tasting, I doubt I could’ve say that’s a 9 years old rum over 70 ABV, the alcohol is very well integrated. Wood, glue, grains, honey, vanilla cream, lemon meringue pie, nutmeg, chalk, marzipan, cocoa, mangoes, raspberries and some light smoke. It’s complex and mysterious in the same time, the profile is a bit different than any other St Lucia I’ve tasted yet.
Mouth: The alcohol integration is as nice as the nose. That’s warm but so sweet in the same time. Leather, honey, grains, raspberries, forest fruits, dark chocolate, nutmeg, white pepper, vanilla cream, peppermint and solvent. The texture is also pleasant. The mouth is at the same level than this nice nose, great!
Finish: Mid-long and slightly drying. Peppermint, blackcurrant, burnt wood, leather and tobacco.

Did I really tasted a 9 years old rum at 70.8%? The result is unquestionably wonderful. That’s classy and refined, very nice and surprising rum!

Score: 91

Two rums that has nearly the same age but very different. The Velier is a great representative of St. Lucia rums, when the Cadenhead’s is more surprising. I enjoyed both but the winner of the day is the Cadenhead’s. One more reason of why I regret to not have the opportunity to taste the second 1999 cask strength St. Lucia bottling from Blackadder yet.
Thanks Arthur for the sample, cheers!

Discover those rums on the RumX app
Velier St. Lucia 70th anniversary 2010-2017
Cadenhead’s St. Lucia 1999-2008

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s